Skip to content
Back to articles

What AI Changes: The Things That Break When It Works

July 27, 2026 5 min read
Share
Brutalist concrete stairs end at a glass wall with an orange cone, showing how AI changing systems impacts design

On a Tuesday morning someone in the pricing team sends round a piece of analysis that would have taken the head of pricing most of a week. It is good. Solid work, and it took her an afternoon.

He reads it twice. The second time he is not checking the numbers. He is working out what he is for.

That moment is the part of AI change that never makes it onto the program plan. The plan tracks licenses, training completion and usage. It has no row for what just happened to the most experienced person in the room.

AI is changing the workplace, though not in the way the headlines suggest. Jobs are not disappearing wholesale and departments are not being automated overnight. What is changing is smaller and harder to see: how decisions get made, where expertise sits, and what it means to be good at a job. Those three things are what many organizations are built on, and none of them appear in the business case.

What the technology moves.

Start with the work itself.

The technology takes over tasks that used to require judgment and surfaces answers that used to require experience. A question that would have gone to the person who had seen it before now gets a competent answer in thirty seconds. That answer is right. Occasionally it is wrong in a way only the person who had seen it before would catch.

So three things move at once. Decisions drift toward whoever is driving the AI. Expertise stops being the thing you go and ask for and becomes the thing you use to check what you were handed. And being good at the job stops meaning you know the answer and starts meaning you know when the answer is wrong.

That last one is difficult to hire for, difficult to train for, and almost impossible to put on a performance review. Many organizations have not tried.

The identity problem nobody puts on the program plan.

When a senior person's expertise stops being scarce, something happens that no training session addresses. They do not lose their job. They lose the thing that made them the person you asked.

That is an identity shift, and identity does not move because someone sat through a two-hour session on prompt writing.

Look at who picked AI up first in your own organization. It is the people who already had high agency and little fear of looking incompetent. They experiment, they fail, they learn, and nothing about their standing depends on already knowing the answer.

The people who hang back are protecting something: twenty years of hard-won judgment, a reputation for being the one who knows, a settled sense of what they are worth here. Using AI badly in front of a colleague puts all of it at risk. What they are avoiding is exposure.

The expertise inversion.

Now run that forward a few cycles.

If the people with the least experience are using AI heavily and the people with the most are holding back, the distance in capability does not close the way you would expect. It inverts.

The junior analyst produces more, faster, across a wider range of problems. The senior one produces at roughly the rate they did last year. Work starts getting routed to whoever moves fastest, and the person with the deepest judgment becomes a bottleneck to be worked around.

You can see it early if you look for it. The senior person stops being copied into the threads where the work gets decided. Their calendar empties of the interesting problems and fills up with approvals. They are still the most capable person in the function, and they are being used as a rubber stamp.

Nobody decides this. It emerges from a thousand small routing choices made by people trying to hit deadlines, and by the time it is visible on an org chart it has already changed who talks to whom.

The missing rung.

Here is the part that shows up years later.

Junior people used to become senior people by doing work that was, frankly, a bit dull. Reconciling the numbers. Drafting the first version. Sitting in on the call and writing it up afterward. Nobody enjoyed those tasks and everybody learned from them. That was the apprenticeship, even in organizations that never used the word.

Those are precisely the tasks the technology is best at.

So the rung people used to climb from is going. You can still hire juniors and you can still hire seniors, but the path between the two is thinning, and the organizations pulling the most productivity out of AI today include the ones removing it fastest. In ten years they will be trying to hire a level of judgment that nobody was given the chance to build.

It is already visible in hiring. A team that would once have taken on three juniors takes one, because the work those roles existed to absorb now happens in the AI. On this year's numbers that reads as efficiency. It is also a decision about who will be capable of running the function in a decade, made by someone optimizing a quarterly budget.

This is what we call the missing rung, and it is one of the central arguments in The Elephant in the Algorithm. None of it is an argument against using the technology. It is an argument for being deliberate about what the technology takes away from people on their way up.

What this asks of a leader.

None of this is solved by buying differently or training harder.

It is solved by being explicit about things many organizations leave implicit: who is learning what and from whom, which tasks exist because they produce output and which exist because they produce people, and what a senior person is for once their recall advantage has gone.

That last one matters more than it sounds. The senior people reading the room right now are making private decisions about their own future, and they are making them without any information from you.

The principle we work to is raise the human rather than remove the human. You can deploy AI so that it takes work off people, or so that it raises what people are capable of. AI does not care which. The design choice is yours, and if nobody makes it on purpose, it gets made by default.

If you want to know how this is landing in your own organization, the AI Profit Ready Assessment gives you a read on it. It is free, and it asks nothing of you except honest answers.

And if you want to talk through what you are seeing, book a discovery call here.

Take it with you

Download this as a PDF

A clean, branded version to read offline or share with your team.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is AI changing inside a company?

Less than the headlines claim and more than the program plan tracks. Jobs are not disappearing wholesale. What changes is how decisions get made, where expertise sits, and what it means to be good at a job. Decisions drift toward whoever is driving the AI, expertise becomes the thing you use to check an answer, no longer the thing you go and ask for, and competence starts to mean knowing when the answer is wrong.

Why do senior employees adopt AI more slowly than junior colleagues?

Because they have more standing to lose. The people who pick AI up first are the ones with high agency and little fear of looking incompetent, since nothing about their position depends on already knowing the answer. Senior people are protecting years of hard-won judgment and a reputation for being the one who knows. Using AI badly in front of a colleague puts that at risk, so what looks like reluctance is an avoidance of exposure.

What is the missing rung?

Junior people used to become senior people by doing the dull work: reconciling the numbers, drafting the first version, writing up the call afterward. Nobody enjoyed those tasks and everybody learned from them. Those are precisely the tasks AI is best at, so the rung people used to climb from is disappearing. You can still hire juniors and seniors, but the path between them is thinning, and the cost lands years later when nobody has been given the chance to build the judgment you need.

How does AI invert the expertise ladder?

If the least experienced people are using AI heavily and the most experienced are holding back, the distance in capability does not close. It inverts. Junior staff produce more across a wider range of problems while senior staff produce at last year's rate, so work gets routed to whoever moves fastest. The person with the deepest judgment becomes a bottleneck to be worked around. It shows up early as a senior person who is no longer copied into the threads where work gets decided, with a calendar full of approvals.

What does raise the human rather than remove the human mean?

It is a design intent. The same technology can be deployed so that it takes work off people, or so that it raises what people are capable of. AI does not care which. The difference is decided by how the work is designed around them, and unless someone makes that choice deliberately, it gets made by default.

What should a leader do about the identity shift AI creates?

Be explicit about what many organizations leave implicit: who is learning what and from whom, which tasks exist because they produce output and which exist because they produce people, and what a senior person is for once their recall advantage has gone. That last one matters most. Senior people are already making private decisions about their own future, and they are making them without any information from you.

Share
Newsletter

With People

The people side of making AI pay.

  • One story from the news about AI at work, read through our book, The Elephant in the Algorithm.
  • A few links worth your time, and sometimes a podcast conversation.
Privacy Policy